Quick Tip - How to Quickly Assess an AR-15

Synopsis: In this quick tip video, Caleb walks through how to perform a fast, visual assessment of an AR-15—especially useful if you’re at a gun show, gun shop, or private sale and want to evaluate a rifle without full disassembly. While nothing beats a full inspection with tools and gauges, this guide helps identify obvious build flaws, red flags, and assembly mistakes using a simple external check.

What You Will Learn: 

• Identify key components of the AR-15 to inspect.

• Learn quick ways to detect wear, damage, or improper assembly.

• Understand basic safety and functionality checks without full disassembly.

• Develop a consistent routine for assessing rifles, especially for builders or techs.

Benefit: Whether you're a hobbyist, a first-time builder, or a seasoned armorer, this video adds real value by sharpening your inspection skills and improving your overall firearm knowledge.

Why a Quick Assessment Matters

Caleb starts by explaining the purpose of this quick check: If you're looking at a rifle and the seller won’t let you disassemble it, or you’re just doing a casual walk-around, this checklist helps you spot issues before committing to a purchase. It’s not a full teardown—just a smart visual once-over.

External Visual Inspection

Begin with a broad visual sweep. Check for anything that looks out of place, missing, or poorly installed. If the rifle is a home build or from an unknown source, look closely for signs of amateur assembly.

Magazine Catch Button

Check the magazine catch screw on the left side. It should be flush or nearly flush with the button. If it’s sticking way out or deeply recessed, it may indicate improper installation—an early red flag that the builder wasn’t familiar with correct assembly.

Castle Nut Orientation and Tightness

The castle nut at the rear of the lower receiver should have the notched side facing back.

• If it’s installed backward: walk away.

• If it’s not staked and can be loosened by hand: another major red flag.

Caleb emphasizes that all castle nuts should be torqued properly and staked to prevent movement during use.

Buffer Tube Alignment

Ensure the buffer tube (receiver extension) is aligned correctly. The spine of the tube should be vertical when viewed from behind. A crooked buffer tube suggests careless assembly.

Grip Fitment and Tightness

Visually inspect the pistol grip. Ensure it’s firmly attached with no wobble. While this is a minor fix, a loose grip can indicate an overall lack of attention to detail.

Takedown and Pivot Pins

Without disassembling the rifle, press both pins to ensure they spring in and out properly.

• They should be spring-loaded and return to position.

• If they feel stuck or misaligned, it could point to internal issues or poor assembly.

Ejection Port Cover Retention

Check that the rod clip on the ejection port cover is installed correctly. If it's missing, the cover rod can walk out over time, which is a functional issue.

Handguard Alignment

Inspect the handguard-to-receiver alignment. It should sit flush and straight with the upper receiver. A crooked handguard can affect your sight alignment and may indicate an improperly installed barrel nut or loose mounting screws.

Barrel and Gas System Inspection

Gas Tube Orientation

Visually inspect the gas tube through the handguard:

• It should curve up from the gas block to the upper receiver.

• If it’s installed upside down, it’s a clear indicator of amateur assembly.

Gas Block Set Screws

Look under the barrel to check that the gas block set screws are present and seated below the surface. Missing or loose screws could mean poor alignment or risk of gas system failure.

Gas Block Alignment

If the seller allows, lock the bolt open and look through the top of the handguard to visually confirm the gas block is aligned with the gas port.

Muzzle Device and Crush Washer

Ensure the muzzle device is secure and the crush washer is installed correctly (flared end facing the muzzle device). If the washer is backwards, that’s another signal the rifle may have been built without proper care.

Controls and Spring Tension Check

Press the mag release, safety selector, bolt catch, and takedown pins to ensure all controls spring properly and feel secure. Nothing should feel gritty, sticky, or loose.

Bonus: Internal Checks (If Allowed)

If the seller allows you to open the rifle, look at a few key areas.

Fire Control Group (Trigger Assembly)

Make sure the hammer spring legs rest on top of the trigger pin. If they’re underneath, the pin can walk out during use and the trigger can lose tension—common with incorrect assembly.

Buffer Retainer

Check that the buffer retainer pin is properly retained by the buffer tube. It shouldn’t fly out during disassembly. Misalignment here can cause the buffer to move freely inside the receiver.

Bolt Carrier Group (BCG)

Gas Key Staking

Inspect the gas key on top of the BCG. It should be properly staked to prevent screws from backing out. Lack of staking = walk away.

Check for Burrs

Look for any machine marks or burrs, especially on the rear rails of the carrier. Caleb notes that cheap BCGs sometimes have burrs that damage buffer tubes over time.

Gas Tube Protrusion

On the upper receiver, ensure the gas tube extends slightly into the receiver where the bolt interfaces. If the tube is recessed too far or misaligned, the rifle won’t cycle.

Feed Ramp Alignment

Look inside the upper and barrel extension. The feed ramps on the upper receiver and barrel should align smoothly. If they don’t, feeding issues can occur, especially with soft-tipped ammo.

Final Thoughts

This quick assessment doesn’t replace a full inspection, but it can help you spot build quality issues, amateur mistakes, and red flags at a glance.

If the rifle passes this checklist, it's a good sign the builder knew what they were doing. If it fails more than one or two areas, it might be worth walking away or digging deeper.

As Caleb reminds viewers, the goal isn’t to roast someone’s build at a gun show—but to make sure you’re spending your money wisely on a quality AR-15 platform.

AR-15 quick inspection, how to check AR-15 quality, AR-15 gun show tips, buying used AR-15, castle nut staking, buffer tube alignment, BCG staking inspection, feed ramp alignment, AR-15 gas block check, how to buy a used AR-15, AR-15 build checklist, bolt carrier inspection, visual AR-15 check, AR-15 red flags